By Francisco Mateo, CPP, CFE
Picture this, you’re company has worldwide operations including some places where it might be stable today, but has a long history of violence. You’d be amazed at the number of countries you can come up with. For the sake of brevity we’d not list them, but the fact remains that we live in a turbulent world where risk is asymmetric and extremely unpredictable. History offers many scenarios to illustrate the point; like:
“American executives isolated in towns throughout Lebanon during the Israeli-Hezbollah conflict. Businessmen in Chad stuck in a hotel in the capital, N’Djamena, as rebels bore down on the city.”
And is not just corporate travel that is impacted by these risk scenarios. Staff at every company vacation all over the world. Some adventurers get their thrills in some of the world’s riskiest places. For instance:
“Ten years ago, 62 tourists and tour guides were massacred at the Temple of Hatshepsut, in Luxor. In 2004, bomb attacks on hotels in the Sinai killed 34. The following year, blasts in downtown Sharm accounted for the deadliest attack in the country’s history, killing 85. Two dozen others were slaughtered in 2006 in the Red Sea resort of Dahab.”
Now, it’s clear that employees must assume and properly mitigate their risk situation. Indeed companies are not obliged to extend aid to the staff in their own time, but it’d be a great value added service to get your people to safety when crisis strikes. That is precisely the aim of an Evacuation Plan (EP), to get your people out of hotspots when things go awry.
As security and travel practitioners, we are always stressing the need to be prepared for the unthinkable. We’re consistently preaching the prevention gospel to our business travelers and expatriate staff. Our toolkit is first equipped with well crafted travel security awareness plans which helps make our travelers and expatriate staff more resilient through training and timely information. But we know that risk trends are like water, travelers could be faced with fluid situations which may not work in their favor. A comprehensive EP should allow us to extricate our travelers or expatriate personnel out of a hotspot in a safe and timely manner.
What are the elements of an effective country evacuation plan?
As an initial step your organization’s Crisis Management Team (CMT) must take on responsibility for the evacuation planning and execution. The CMT is well suited for the task since they are most likely to know the risk the organization is exposed to and has created plans to mitigate them. This superior knowledge bodes well for identifying and quickly reacting to conditions that would merit staff evacuations.
That said, planning an evacuation is an exacting business with many moving parts. A crisis event that merits an evacuation of staff must account for a number of potential eventualities that may include:
- political – military instability or upheaval
- a break-down in law and order, and a consequent state of chaos, or anarchy
- an unacceptable deterioration in living conditions
- widespread criminal and/or terrorist actions
- war in the region
- natural disasters such as flood, famine, earthquakes, disease and epidemics
All the scenarios mentioned above are likely to lead to situations where there are unacceptable dangers to life, or where business activities cannot profitably be pursued. The response to such scenarios is likely to be full or partial evacuation of expatriate personnel and dependants as well as foreign business visitors.
The following are guiding principles that are part of the pre-planning and execution of any EP best practice procedures:
- Enable rational and logical decisions to be made; and create a decision-making organization
- Establish reliable sources of information/intelligence
- Establish communication requirements
- Delegate duties and responsibilities to expatriate personnel
- Establish and set up procedures aimed at enhancing the security of the evacuees
- Implement such procedures quickly and efficiently
- The safety and well-being of the employees and dependants is of the utmost
- Alert states and triggers are clearly defined
- The decision making authority, and individual responsibilities, are clearly defined and understood
- Timely and accurate situation reports and up-to-date threat assessments must be available to assist balanced judgments by the CMT and the organization’s senior management
- Reliable communications and reporting procedures are in place
- Affected employees and dependants would be well briefed on relevant components of the plan
- Updated records of the locations and contact details of all potential evacuees would be maintained
- Necessary administrative details and support would be pre-planned
- Business continuity and recovery plans are in place and up to date
- Security of personnel in an atmosphere of fear, speculation and rumor would be maintained
- Close liaison with relevant political, law enforcement and diplomatic missions would be maintained
- Non-expatriate staff are neither endangered nor financially disadvantaged.
A decision to evacuate a country is obviously of vital importance to the continuity of the business. For that matter a short span of control must be maintained on the decision making process. The senior most executive in-country acting as the CMT leader and in close coordination with the organization’s board of directors (or designee) should have the final say of when to evacuate.
Means of Evacuation:
If an evacuation is inevitable and the situation requires the activation of the EP, commercial flights will be favored. However, there is a high probability of overcrowded or incapacitated national and international airports. Some airlines may cease flying to areas of conflict. A crucial provision in the EP should account for evacuation through:
- Airborne evacuation by chartered or corporate aircrafts or helicopters
- Overland evacuation by chartered coaches or private convoys
- Where practicable, sea evacuation by chartered boats
Developing Alarm Triggers
Although crisis events seldom give warnings, the type of events that would trigger an evacuations follow a cascading sequence of events that can be interpreted through a series of alert states. It’s the duty of the security/safety practitioner to advice the CMT on a prudent course of action if economic, political or social environment would progressively deteriorate.
Alert State One
Alert State Two
Alert State Three
Alert State Four
|Threat of natural disaster in region
||Serious natural disaster with loss of some essential services.
||Loss of all essential services with risk of disease and epidemic
||Sudden loss of all essential services with high risk of disease and epidemic
|Militantdemonstrations and protests
||Civil unrest, rioting etc., making local travel unsafe; paralysis of some services
||Loss of all essential services and significant risk when traveling locally
||Sudden violent protests and demonstrations paralyzing … making local travel impossible
Political and Military unrest
||Considerable disruption to government with loss of some essential services
||Political take overLoss of all essential services
||Sudden coupRebellionLoss of all essential services
|Cooling in diplomatic relations
||Severing of diplomatic relations
||Hostile diplomatic relations
||Seizure of foreign owned assets
|Regional armed conflict
||Spread of regional conflict
||Major conflict involving …
||Unforeseen major conflict involving …
|Policies disagreeable to international community
||Imposition of international sanctions
||Serious shortage of essential commodities
Threat of Violence and/or Terrorism
|Threat against foreign people
||Threat against your employees and assets
||Terrorist action against your staff or other foreign companies
||Threats of kidnapping, or assassination of your employees
|Isolated terrorist action
||Effective terrorist action
||Major terrorist campaign
||Sudden terrorist campaign launched in …
The Alert State are defined as follows:
||Political and security risk factors justify the preparation of an evacuation procedureBusiness activity can continue as normal
||Activate the CMTMonitor the threat in co-operation with Security PractitionerReview and update the EP
|Alert State OneCaution
||Potential for the security situation to deteriorate rapidly
||Business travel is possible with careful considerationCMT meets once a week for monitoringUpgrade security
Keep EP ready for immediate implementation
|Alert State TwoStand-by
||Security situation and/or country instability represents a risk to employees, families and physical assets
||Avoid non-essential business travel (Market and Zone restriction)CMT meets once a week for monitoringActivate Task Force (TF) for co-ordination
Security at high level
Minimize local movement
Undertake a local security assessment and
- if the threat is manageable, dependants and visitors can remain on site with evacuation procedures ready to activate
- if the threat is not manageable, ordered the withdrawal of dependants and visitors.
|Alert State ThreeEvacuation with stay behind presence
||Business severely disrupted and high risk of exposure to staff
||CMT in co-ordination with TF withdraw all expatriate staff but stay-behind group of key staff remain on siteAssistance and logistic provided by evacuation transport providerSecure all sites including residences, other assets and information
|Alert State FourEmergency evacuation
||Extreme risk to personnel and company assets
||CMT in co-ordination with TF withdraw all international staff
||Initial temporary basing of evacuated personnel in an another country rather than their home
||Implement Business Continuity PlansDecide whether to repatriate staff or keep them in the temporary locationAdministrative and HR management
||It is now considered safe for certain or all personnel to return to country/site
||Progressive re-deployment of resourcesReactivation of business operationReverse Alert State actions
Like any crisis plan the EP should consider Make the decision to partially, or fully evacuate expatriate personnel under any circumstances. The plan should contemplate the many things that can go wrong during a crisis (breakdown in communication, mandatory curfew, martial law etc.) . Consider also the financial resources needed to see the evacuation to a successful completion. Consider also the decision making and delegation of control and responsibilities. If the senior executive is incapacitated or unable to carryout his/her duty during a crisis event, who’d assume the decision making responsibilities? Develop your CMT task and duties and make them part of your EP. Each incumbent should be familiar with their duties and responsibilities as well as the others within the CMT. This can be achieved by rotating CMT duties among its members and conducting mock drills to those ends.
Communication is one of the pillars of crisis plans without an effective communications at all levels important task would go uncompleted compromising the eventual success of the EP. Start by developing a contact list of all devices for your CMT. Many emergency communications services offer automated call trees which seamlessly send out message blasts to designated individuals in your tree. Make use of cutting edge crisis technology to gain speed and efficiency when executing an evacuation.
While communicating externally the preparation of a statement also requires careful planning and consideration.
- Never make a statement without first making sure that the key messages you wish to express have been properly defined.
- Make sure you are aware of as much of the context as possible of the situation you will be discussing.
- Call upon the services of the Corporate Communications who can help give you a better understanding of the aspects you are not necessarily familiar with.
- Make sure you can refer to dispositions implemented previously in order to prevent the type of incident you are going to discuss (forms filled in prior to the event).
- Make sure you are aware of all the information that may be referred to during the statement (forms filled in prior to the event.
- Concentrate on the key messages you identified beforehand.
- Keep the statement simple, concise, precise.
- Do not extrapolate, branch out on another subject, or try to hide part of the truth; be honest sincere and credible.
- Do not accept responsibility or place responsibility on a third party for the facts.
- Always bear in mind that what is stated to the press will be read by all the company’s audiences, both internal and external.
Order of Evacuation
The general chronology of an evacuation will be:
All dependants of expatriate employees, business visitors and third party employees.
- Non-essential staff.
- Stay-behind and remaining key staff.
Continuity of the business concern is also of vital importance and should be treated as such in the EP. Even under crisis situations certain products must get to market. To ensure continuity of your business, Identify key facts about the operation; identify primary and secondary sites, as well as subsidiaries. Consider the situation how is business likely to be disrupted? How can business continue under alternative management measures? Designate a person responsible for business operation during an evacuation and lay out their protocols. Develop a contingency arrangement for all sites and business area (Sales, production, supply chain, finance IT, etc.). Develop the means of communication enabling remote advice by proxy from central location away from the conflict. Take into considerations the priority in providing services or products to your costumers. Arrange proper protection for stay-behind staff, assets and products.
Lastly remember that most crisis conditions arise suddenly and would allow lengthy deliberation about what to do. A well formulated evacuation plan would give you the flexibility to operate your business anywhere in the world while maintaining your personnel safe, protecting your assets, product and perpetuating business operations. Your shareholders would not expect any less. The truth of the matter is that such plans were reserved for exotic hot spots, but in our fragmenting world where risk is asymmetric and extremely unpredictable these scenarios are fast becoming the norm anywhere. If you plan well, you’d execute diligently and get back to operations faster. This would ensure the most leverage from the opportunities every crisis intrinsically provides.